Caston

Celebrity voting, solution size, as well as the right answers

I've been noticing some developments about responses on Quora more than the final 5-6 months, and i imagined I would share them in a put up briefly, as well as in no unique purchase, below are my observations:

   Voting up a celeb remedy w/o following the question and without having examining other answers submitted after the celeb writes his or her solution is potentially reckless. Okay, reckless is usually a strong word, but seriously, it will not enable ensure the best answer or, in some conditions, the proper answer, gets near the leading. As an illustration, a 2-3 people (bravely, I might incorporate) submitted answers to the query that Larry Summers added. On this distinct thread, Summers solution the query finest, but -- let's say, imagine if -- anyone or a number of people included solutions which were much better, but never ever obtained recognized due to a hit-and-run movie star vote?
   The longest solution is not really generally the very best (or right solution). I have found there are some really, seriously lengthy responses to issues that happen to be exciting but use 3-4x volume of words to obtain to your similar point. Yet, there appears to be some type of psychological preference for for a longer time answers that give a lot more detail (and oftentimes added opinion) in the event the query posed won't really warrant it. The person inquiring the issue may just want the answer, not excess answers sprinkled with far too quite a few thoughts.
   On thoughts that have unique suitable responses, I check out to not only vote (after i do vote), but to comment on the solution also, stating with my name evidently that this is the right reply. I figured this out on a totally insignificant concern which has a single clear remedy, but discovered that 7-8 individuals wrote these theories about how to answer the dilemma. They all experienced random votes, but were obviously incorrect. I voted up the best reply (which didn't make it for the prime), after which you can commented on the reply, "This will be the proper remedy." Now, for this one, I understand I'm correct, and that i wouldn't make this happen often, but this type of technique may possibly assistance on sure queries. Possibly  in the future, PeopleRank should help the votes be weighted accurately image voting.